1. Introduction
Internal thread machining—commonly referred to as tapping—is one of the most widespread operations in mechanical manufacturing. Despite its apparent simplicity, tapping is also one of the most failure-prone processes on the shop floor. Broken taps, poor thread surface quality, oversized or undersized threads, and unstable tool life are frequently encountered issues.
In practice, many of these problems do not originate from machine rigidity or operator skill, but from an incorrect match between tap design and the workpiece material. Different metals vary significantly in hardness, ductility, work-hardening tendency, thermal conductivity, and chip-forming behavior. These variations impose fundamentally different requirements on tap material, flute geometry, coating, and tapping strategy.
This article systematically discusses how to select appropriate taps for different metallic materials, focusing on engineering logic, material behavior, and real-world manufacturing experience. The objective is to provide a practical reference for process engineers, manufacturing engineers, and CNC programmers.
—
2. Key Factors Influencing Tap Selection
Before addressing specific materials, it is essential to understand the core parameters that govern tap performance.
2.1 Workpiece Material Characteristics
The following material properties are critical:
Hardness (HB / HRC)
Ductility and toughness
Work-hardening tendency
Chip morphology (powdery, segmented, or continuous)
Thermal conductivity
2.2 Machining Conditions
Manual tapping vs. machine tapping
Rigid tapping vs. floating tapping
Through holes vs. blind holes
2.3 Tap Design Parameters
Substrate material (HSS, HSS-E, PM-HSS, carbide)
Flute type (straight, spiral, spiral-point)
Rake angle and relief
Coating type
A correct tap selection is always the result of matching these factors, not relying on a single parameter.
—
3. Tap Selection for Carbon Steels and Alloy Steels
3.1 Low-Carbon Steels (e.g., Q235, AISI 1018)
Material characteristics:
Low strength and hardness
High ductility
Long, continuous chips
Tendency for built-up edge formation
Recommended taps:
Tap material: Standard HSS
Flute type: Straight flute or spiral flute (15°–35°)
Coating: Uncoated or TiN
Rake angle: Large positive rake
Practical notes:
Spiral flute taps significantly improve chip evacuation
Adequate lubrication is critical to prevent chip adhesion
—
3.2 Medium-Carbon and Quenched-and-Tempered Steels
(e.g., AISI 1045, 42CrMo)
Material characteristics:
Higher strength and hardness
Increased cutting resistance
Moderate work-hardening tendency
Recommended taps:
Tap material: HSS-E (cobalt-alloyed HSS)
Flute type: Spiral flute for blind holes, straight flute for through holes
Coating: TiN or TiCN
Machining method: Prefer rigid machine tapping
Engineering recommendations:
Drill hole size should be close to the upper tolerance limit
Avoid excessive cutting speed to reduce thermal stress
—
3.3 High-Strength Alloy Steels (>35 HRC)
Material characteristics:
High hardness and toughness
Elevated cutting temperature
Severe abrasive and adhesive wear
Recommended taps:
Tap material: PM-HSS or solid carbide
Flute type: Short spiral or specialized high-hardness tap geometry
Coating: AlTiN or TiAlN
Tapping strategy: Low speed, high rigidity
Important considerations:
Conventional HSS taps exhibit extremely short tool life
Axial alignment and concentricity are critical
—
4. Tap Selection for Stainless Steels
Stainless steels are among the most challenging materials for tapping and account for a high percentage of tap breakage cases.
4.1 Austenitic Stainless Steels (304 / 316)
Material characteristics:
Extremely high ductility
Severe work-hardening
Poor thermal conductivity
Recommended taps:
Tap material: HSS-E or PM-HSS
Flute type: High-helix spiral flute (35°–45°)
Coating: TiCN or AlTiN
Rake angle: Large positive rake
Critical process controls:
Never interrupt the tapping cycle once started
Avoid “stop-and-go” motion
High-performance extreme-pressure cutting fluid is mandatory
—
4.2 Martensitic Stainless Steels (420 / 440)
Material characteristics:
High hardness
Reduced ductility
Increased brittleness
Tap selection guidelines:
Prefer tapping in the annealed condition
Use PM-HSS or carbide taps
Reduce cutting speed to prevent edge chipping
—
5. Tap Selection for Aluminum Alloys
5.1 Common Aluminum Alloys (6061, 5052)
Material characteristics:
Soft and highly ductile
Strong tendency for material adhesion
Poor chip breakability
Recommended taps:
Tap material: HSS
Flute type: Large-helix spiral flute
Coating: Uncoated or DLC
Rake angle: Very large positive rake
Engineering experience:
Highly polished cutting edges outperform most coatings
TiN coatings are generally not recommended due to aluminum adhesion
—
5.2 High-Silicon Aluminum Alloys (e.g., ADC12)
Material characteristics:
High silicon content
Pronounced abrasive wear
Recommended taps:
Tap material: PM-HSS or carbide
Coating: TiCN
Flute type: Straight flute or low-helix design
—
6. Tap Selection for Copper and Copper Alloys
6.1 Pure Copper and Brass
Material characteristics:
Extremely soft
High ductility
Severe chip adhesion
Recommended approach:
Straight flute taps
Small rake angle
Mirror-polished cutting edges
Proper lubrication to reduce adhesion
—
6.2 Bronze and Beryllium Copper
Material characteristics:
Higher hardness than brass
Moderate abrasive wear
Recommended taps:
Tap material: HSS-E or PM-HSS
Coating: TiN or TiCN
Cutting speed: Medium to low
—
7. Tap Selection for Cast Iron
Material characteristics:
Brittle
Chips break into powder or small fragments
No adhesion tendency
Recommended taps:
Tap material: HSS
Flute type: Straight flute
Coating: Uncoated or TiN
Lubrication: Dry cutting or minimal coolant
Notes:
Gray cast iron is easier to tap than ductile iron
Spiral flute taps are generally unnecessary and may clog
—
8. Application of Forming (Roll) Taps
Forming taps are not universal replacements for cutting taps.
Suitable materials:
Aluminum alloys
Low-carbon steels
Selected stainless steels (with dedicated geometry)
Unsuitable materials:
Cast iron
High-hardness steels
Brittle alloys
Key requirements:
Precise pre-drilled hole size
Excellent lubrication
High machine rigidity
—
9. Common Mistakes in Tap Selection
1. Using a single tap type for all materials
2. Ignoring the relationship between material and drill size
3. Applying straight flute taps to austenitic stainless steel
4. Using standard HSS taps for hardened steels
5. Selecting coatings without considering material compatibility
